Light Snow; Mist 19°
Light Snow; Mist 
School Closings | 5 Day Forecast | Radar
Man hurt following fight at Tuskies, police need help

October 14, 2008 - 04:02 a.m. EST

An Alpena man needed to be airlifted to a downstate hospital following a fight Saturday, at Tuskies.

City of Alpena police were called to the bar shortly before 2 a.m., after being told one of the two men was down. The 26 year-old victim was originally taken to the local hospital and later transferred to St. Mary’s in Saginaw with serious head injuries.

Members of the Huron Undercover Narcotics Team (HUNT) assisted in the initial investigation and helped identify the suspect. The 27 year-old man was subsequently arrested and jailed on a charge of assault with intent to murder. He is being held on a one-million-dollar bond.

The investigation continues and anyone with information on this incident is asked to contact police at 354-1800.

Comments

Readers are solely responsible for the content of the comments they post here. Comments are subject to the site's terms and conditions of use and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of True North Radio. Readers whose comments violate the terms of use may have their comments removed or all of their content blocked from viewing by other users without notification.

  1. October 13, 2008

    9:42 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    kittie (Anonymous) says...

    Anyone know the names of these individuals?

  2. October 13, 2008

    9:49 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    HotRodAMX (Anonymous) says...

    I was told,Dave marjlowski Jr. And Rob Marshall. It`s too bad it has come to this....Dave is in jail.

  3. October 14, 2008

    2:01 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    fromalpena (Anonymous) says...

    That marlewski guy was just busted by hunt not too many days ago

  4. October 14, 2008

    5:37 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    AlpenaWoman (Anonymous) says...

    They say Dave was involved but from what I hear it may not be him. We have to remember this is a bar fight and sometimes stories of drunks aren't all that good. I also know hunt has a pending charge on Dave... saying someone wore a wire. But he has yet to be charged with anything for that.

  5. October 14, 2008

    6:52 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    fromalpena (Anonymous) says...

    True, at 2:00am most people are plastered and probably don't make good witnesses. Tuskies is notorious for overserving people.

  6. October 14, 2008

    11:11 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    mandy1 (Anonymous) says...

    I don't know what happened but I hope that whoever put the kid in the hospital pays for it. It is very sad that something like that had to happen, no matter what the fight was over. Alpena is beginning to get alot of crime, and that is pretty sad.

  7. October 15, 2008

    11:18 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    peny (Anonymous) says...

    Regardless what the fight was about who gives anyone the right to hurt a person that bad? What a shame someones life is now messed up because tempers take over. I can't believe others stood by and let this happen. What has our town come too??????

  8. October 16, 2008

    9:50 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    EMP (Anonymous) says...

    I'm curious as to where the line is drawn on what gets the police involved and media attention. Early saturday morning on July 26th Dick McDonald was attacked, UNPROVOKED, outside of the Holiday Inn by 4 or 5 men, had a beer bottle broken over his head and was rushed to the hospital. No arrests have been made and nothing was ever mentioned on the news or radio. If Marchlewski is being charged with Assault with Intent to Commit Murder, than what is the difference on what he did and what the men who attacked Dick did?

  9. October 16, 2008

    10:55 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    puma (Anonymous) says...

    A warrant was issued in the McDonald incident It was for aggravated assault. Al Charboneau Jr. is out on $7,000.00 bond.

  10. October 16, 2008

    10:59 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    mherriman (Anonymous) says...

    Completely agree with the above comment. The officer involved was Brooks and nothing has been done. He promised to stay in touch and oops so much for that. Dick McDonald's injuries could have been life threatening as well. The officer even had the name of one of the perpetrators, and instead of getting a warrant right away, they called him and asked him to come to the police station. Like this type of person would really just voluntarily walk into the police station. Alan Sharboneau was one of the perpetrators. over a month later a warrant was issued and now it appears to be a dead end. So much for feeling safe.

  11. October 16, 2008

    3:43 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    kittie (Anonymous) says...

    I was told that Rob passed away yesterday. I know this is alpena, and it is a rumor mill, but does anyone know if this is true?

  12. October 16, 2008

    4:14 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    Starboard (Anonymous) says...

    mherriman: Just because it was Brooks as the investigating officer doesn't mean that he himself dropped the ball. If he did his investigation and turned it over to the Prosecutor's office that is where it pretty much stops (not completely) for him until that office issues the warrant. Personally I hadn't heard anything about this so I cannot say who is at fault for dropping the ball but if knowing the Pros office, DPG probably let it sit there on his desk or at his home. This Al Charbonneau that you speak of is this the same one that shot at the trooper's a few years ago? Interesting if it was.

  13. October 16, 2008

    7:17 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenagirl (Anonymous) says...

    I heard that they were not even at the bar and that Dave was looking for Ron and saw him walking. I heard that he hit him and Ron fell and hit his head on the curb. I also heard that someone walked out of the bar and saw Dave kicking Ron in the head multiple times and that it was very bloody. If Dave were looking for Ron, he wouldn't have gone alone, so who was with him and why didn't they stop Dave??? I wonder what Dave is thinking about in jail?

  14. October 17, 2008

    7:51 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    no ron has not passed he has woke up and is getting better everyday. this is alpena people you cant' listen to rumors.

  15. October 17, 2008

    10:45 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    thinking1 (Anonymous) says...

    starboard is right, it is not officer Brooks, it is our pathetic prosecutors office. the officer turns everything over to the prosecutors and then the prosecutor has the almighty power.

  16. October 17, 2008

    11:17 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    EMP (Anonymous) says...

    There is still no reasons it took 3 months for an arrest, if any(Mr. McDonald was never notified of an arrest, and has been poorly informed of any ongoings in this case). Brooks was given names and location where they were going that night of the incident. Yet the police were never sent after Charbonneau that evening, when they for sure could have been caught "Red Handed" so to speak as they would have been covered in blood from Mr. McDonald's head and face.

  17. October 17, 2008

    12:51 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    theshark (Anonymous) says...

    I do not know where you get your information from EMP-but you are wrong, you are spreading flase information about Brooks and what happend that evening.

    Time delays of three months are inexcusable on most cases. However many cases sit on the desk at the prosecutors office for months before they get around to reading them and making any type of decision. More times than not, the delay is on them. Not the police.

    I feel for any victims now as DG sure the hell is not any ball of fire in his last few weeks, old "experence matters Judy" is off until her election probably with body man Lonnie counting Black signs which leaves dynamite Don at the helm as head chief, cook and bottle washer.

  18. October 17, 2008

    1:46 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    EMP (Anonymous) says...

    Oh. Sorry "the Shark" I didn't know you were present at the time of the attack, as I get my information first hand from Dick. Brooks has not been in contact with him for a well over a month with any information on the case. Now his hospital bills are pileing up with no restitution in site. Doesn't make much sense to have to foot the bill for being a victim.

  19. October 17, 2008

    1:54 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    puma (Anonymous) says...

    CORRECTION
    Yesterday I said that Charboneau was arrested. He HAS NOT.
    He is not the one who shoot at a trooper a few years back. It was his father. Guess the apple didn't fall far Eh?

  20. October 17, 2008

    2:01 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    Starboard (Anonymous) says...

    EMP why the attack on Brooks??? if a warrant was issued out of the Prosecutor's office that would be up to the Victim's Advocate(s) to notify Mr. McDonald of any arrest, court date, etc. He should be paying his bills and turning all receipts over to the advocate so that she could collect restitution for him when the day comes that the Prosecutor's office decides to take it to court. That is if they don't dismiss all cases when or if Judi looses. Don't be surprised if that happens either! If you are fired up about this now, just wait to see if she does loose.

  21. October 17, 2008

    4:50 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    kmandor (Anonymous) says...

    Starboard.........'lose' is spelled with one 'o'.
    Secondly EMP has not attacked Officer Brooks, just the process in general. (though the police were called to the beating of Mr McDonald, and subsequently left with a shrug. Mr McDonald's son had to retrieve his truck--which was covered/surrounded by blood--the next day). Why can one man be attacked and sent to the hospital with no one concerned, while another is attacked and the news is 'front page'?

  22. October 17, 2008

    6:10 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    Starboard (Anonymous) says...

    Kmandor: Sorry!!! I am sure that I am not the only one that has had a grammatical or misspelled error. It is or was in my opinion (which I am entitled to) that EMP was placing blame on Brooks for this also.
    Now getting to the point at hand. I could not agree with you more on why one case gets media attention vs. another case. I have tried to figure that out for a while. There are a couple cases that I could point out that have had similar results.

  23. October 17, 2008

    6:53 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    EMP (Anonymous) says...

    I'm not fully placing the blame on Brooks. Just stating that there is more that could/should have been done that night. As well that his follow up has been less than desired to a victim that is eagerly awaiting some sort of "Justice". I'm sure there are others at fault with the time delays.
    And as I stated in my original post... such a stiff charge for Marchlewski, yet only aggravated assault for Charbonneau. Sure Marchlewski's victim ended up in much worse condition, but Dick could have very well shared the same fate. If someone is swinging a beer bottle, or delivering kicks to someone's head they are meaning GREAT bodily harm.

  24. October 17, 2008

    8:54 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    blindjustice (Anonymous) says...

    hey alpenagirl, It is very clear your under educated. You seem to believe and spread rumors without facts. You rank right up there with all the other unintelligable, drunks who make this town a joke.

  25. October 17, 2008

    9:32 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    jesseinalpena (Anonymous) says...

    Blindjustice......you are very rude.....alpenagirl did not spread rumors she said "I HEARD" that they were not at the bar and that he was looking for him and that he was kicked in the head....she didn't say it happened that way. Maybe you should reread things before you call people names!!! I noticed that you didn't call kitty names for asking a question about what she " heard" I believe that you are the only under educated drunk on here.

  26. October 18, 2008

    1:41 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    AlpenaWoman (Anonymous) says...

    I think the biggest reason why Mr. McDonald's case was not on the news is simply because of Dave's last name. It is a good question on why Al Charbonneau and the others involved were not picked up that night or shortly after. But the Prosecutor's office had a warrent for Dave the next after noon, with no proof. I guess if someone doesn't hospitalize you then your beating must not be as bad. I also think it is crazy that they can have Dave since you are innocent till proven guilty. But The HUNT team wants to get Dave, notice that they assested in the arrest. They have for awhile wanted to nail him on anything. I think if you have to start a statement with "I heard..." then you should just keep it to yourself.

  27. October 18, 2008

    2:39 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    this has nothing to do with dave's name, it has to do with the severity of the beating and then witnesses that came forward that lead to his arrest

  28. October 18, 2008

    2:58 p.m.

    midnightgypsy (Anonymous) says...

    (This comment was removed by the site staff.)

  29. October 18, 2008

    3:06 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    well if the fish was wearing a wire wouldn't the police know exactly what happened....as far as the rest of the hunt team stuff midnightgypsy said, i agree

  30. October 18, 2008

    3:10 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    mrsjimmyurine (Anonymous) says...

    well dave is known in this town as is his dad, and yes he was busted by teh hunt team. some guy named Dave Blackabee or something to that effect set him up

  31. October 18, 2008

    3:37 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    HotRodAMX (Anonymous) says...

    I also have to agree with midnightgypsy...What a crock,at our expense. It`s ok mr. child molester. Just tell us where someone has the dope and we`ll make it easy on ya. Actually we`ll turn you loose!All you have to do is move,and of coarse we`ll pay for that for ya.Now who has what???

  32. October 18, 2008

    6:17 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    tankswarriors (Anonymous) says...

    Dave deserves everything that he gets! Im pretty sure he'll try to blame someone else for his misfortune to get the lighter sentence. I say let him fry! He's been having his daddy buy his way out of trouble for years, seems to me daddy wont be able to get him out of this one. Right about now hes probablly thinking, what the h*ll did I just do.

  33. October 18, 2008

    6:21 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    theshark (Anonymous) says...

    If you did not do drugs, you would not have the problems that come with them. Not to hard to figure this out. No drugs, no hunt no arrests not half the beatings, thefts and the list goes on. Start making some smart decisions people. Wake up.

  34. October 18, 2008

    6:52 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    AlpenaWoman (Anonymous) says...

    What does Dave's name have to do with it, and his father? I have known Dave's father for years and you could not find a better person!! Ron and his brother's all have been feed many meals by Dave's father, when their own mother was not home and their father was not around. By the way Ron lived with Dave Jr. and his mother for awhile when he had no where to go. What ever happened to a person being innocent until proven guilty. As far as the witnesses, how reliable are they after drinking till 2 in the AM. There where witnesses that also stated that Dave was in the bar and when he came out the fight was pretty much over and that Ron was not kicked but, hit his head on the curb when he fell, they did not see Dave hit or kick Ron. What about the other people involved in the fight, or the bystanders, most of them are saying they were not even there, when their names were given to the police by witnesses, whom were not drinking. Seems to me when a person refuses to work with Hunt, and is willing to go to court against there charges, they become hell bent on getting that person one way or another.
    I personally saw Dave with the same clothing on when all this was supposable to have happened and their was no blood on him - he looked like he just got out of the shower and put on clean clothing, nothing on his boots either, as well as no markings on his face or hands to indicate a fight.This is not something I "HEARD", it is what I saw.
    I talked to Ron's father and he said that Ron was released from ICU today. His father whom he will not talk to, because it is his fault for all of Ron's problem with drugs and being in prison. The father who had to leave town to find empolyment, and who has called Ron through out the years, but Ron will not take his calls - the same dad who calls the hospital everyday and Ron will not talk to.
    Do I think anyone deserves to be beaten to the point of haveing to go to the hospital NO not at all. But Ron was throwing punches outside the bar. Just like blaming his dad for everything, he needs to start taking some responsiblity for his own actions. Isn't he on probation and just released from prison this spring. What the hell is he doing, didn't he learn anything!

  35. October 18, 2008

    8:41 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    zippo12 (Anonymous) says...

    Thank You Alpena Woman You Said it all!!!! Nobody knowns what really happen that night.

  36. October 18, 2008

    8:58 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    tankswarriors (Anonymous) says...

    Blah, Blah, Blah, they wouldnt be holding the guy on a million dollar bond if they didnt have some type of proof of his involvement. Like all the witnesses placing him at the scene. we'll see as the case unravels..... As citizsens you have the right to attend the hearings, i know it would be interesting to attend to see what really happened.

  37. October 18, 2008

    9:28 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    zippo12 (Anonymous) says...

    So, were you there Mr tankswarriors or is just gossip

  38. October 18, 2008

    9:44 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    blindjustice (Anonymous) says...

    Updated info. if anyone is interested. Aaron Bensman was arrested inconnection for this fight, in which he bragged about Tuesday night in Jonsey's, I was there talked with him, didn't hear about it. He has 9 warrants, a previous felony assault in Alpena, and 2 more felony's out of Ohio. He also left the state of ohio without doing his prison term of 17 months. He is being held without any bond. As far as shoe prints on Ron, very visible and very large tennis shoe print. He is the one who started all of this and I hope he is man enough to take blame. I wonder why he has so many teeth knocked out. Trust me I will be at all these hearings, but they are not going to be open to the public for scrutiny and personal, and verbal comments.

  39. October 18, 2008

    10:21 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    jesseinalpena (Anonymous) says...

    tankswarriors I guess they had some type of proof against the guy from dons ford since they arrested him????? In alpena they find the proof after they arrest you ! I don't remember the guys name but he caught his house on fire in alpena about 5 years ago, because his wife left him, he got like 20 years or something! something in alpena seems very unfair about how they do things

  40. October 18, 2008

    11:49 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    you know what im so sick of rumors and i heard this and that yes ron has shoe prints all over him which is wrong no matter who did it and what it was about the only reason somebody would stomp on some ones head is to seriously injure or kill somebody. i am friends with both people that are involved in this nobody deserves there head stomped in ever!!!!!!!!!! ron did not snitch on anybody if he did why would he spend so many years in prison, and if david did this he deserves everything he gets and if its someone else, same to them. i am soooooooo sick of the rumors and i heard. ron is like a stroke victom he will have a long road of recovery ahead of him, david also. i wish that all this did not happpen but it did and i guess we all will see with the trial that will go on. aaron was not arrested due to this fight he had felony warrants. mike was not arrested due to this crime, it was parole violations, for being at the bar and out after curfue of his parole. this is all over a stupid little girl that likes to sleep around, and it makes me sick. aarons bond is just over $6000 and he can be out. ron will be going through a lot of therapy and cant get out of the situation no matter how much money he has, i dont' think davids dads money will get him out of this one but i wish him the best there were a few witnesses that were not drinkin that night and were completely sober and yes there testimony counts and if it counts against dave so be it. and as far as rons dad he is a drunk that never had any thing to do with rons life so what would be the difference now. ron knows the difference and he does not want him there. after someone beats you up and your on the ground does that make you tougher to stomp his head in. NO!!!! it makes you a pussy that has to screw with a guy thats down yep thats mannly
    ha

  41. October 19, 2008

    12:04 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    you can all hate for what i said but i just want all to know that it is not what i heard or how i feel it's what i know

  42. October 19, 2008

    12:09 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    ron and dave's life will never be the same and that is sad that this had to happen they were friends with eachother and i am sure neither one wanted this to happen. but it did and everyone needs to deal with it.

  43. October 19, 2008

    12:11 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    Well, well gina, sence you seem to know everthing why don't you let everyone in on your infomation and stop the gossip. What does Ron say who did this to him?? I heard all he wants to do is get out of the hospital so he can go get drunk, or is that a rumor as well? What type of shoe prints does he really have boot or tennis shoe prints? Let everyone know and stop the rummors!

  44. October 19, 2008

    12:17 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    Gina sounds like you have been judge and jury for Dave. Yes it is a sad sad thing that happened to Ron and no one should have to go through anything like that no matter what!!!!!

  45. October 19, 2008

    12:56 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    Ron's dad might be a drunk as you say, but does that give him the right to blam all of his actions on him. My dad is a drunk, thats why I do drugs and drink, he's the reason I went to prison. Grow up Ron and take responsibility for your own actions. Wasn't Ron in a fight prior to this one, could not the brusing you say you saw on him be from his previous fights?? And yes there are witnesses to these fights also.

  46. October 19, 2008

    5:54 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenamd (Anonymous) says...

    Wow! Looks like Alpenawoman (Val) knows quite a bit about everything! Looks like nobody but the Shark knows that these things, including the work that HUNT has to do, wouldn't happen if people in this town could leave ILLEGAL drugs alone and learn how to drink like responsible ADULTS. Too many people in Alpena are in need of baby sitters that where uniforms. They need to grow up. Also, that silly fight club and the figting school on the north side don't set a very good example either. Just adds to the violence and teaches drug users, dealers, and drunks to beat eachother better.

  47. October 19, 2008

    10:11 a.m.

    midnightgypsy (Anonymous) says...

    (This comment was removed by the site staff.)

  48. October 19, 2008

    10:45 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenamd (Anonymous) says...

    Midnightgypsy sounds like so ignorant when she says things like be a man and take your punishment. And let the hunt do there own work. don't be a snitch. etc.

    If everyone thought like this, this town would be a wreck. Why is it so wrong to help the police catch drug dealers? Maybe if more people would quite thinking like Midnightgypsy we wouldn't have gang graffiti painted on the walls on the north side and there wouldn't be all this drunken drugged out violence. This stuff about snitches and being a man is so lame.

  49. October 19, 2008

    1:50 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    Midnightgypsy it's not my dad it is Ron's - Ron is the one who blames everything on his dad. Yes my father was also a drunk, a very abusive drunk - but I take responsibility for my own actions - I don't do drugs, drink only socially (a few glasses of wine every now and then), have a family that I take care of, went to college and have a degree and a full time job. I made the choice not to have the life my father had or give that type of life to my family. Maybe you should read what I said before jumping to your own conclusions.

  50. October 19, 2008

    2:14 p.m.

    midnightgypsy (Anonymous) says...

    (This comment was removed by the site staff.)

  51. October 19, 2008

    2:30 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    midnightgypsy (Anonymous) says...

    To Alpenawoman: I am sorry I misunderstood what you were saying when I said what I said to you. The way you wrote it led me to believe you were speaking about you and your dad, my mistake! I don't contribute on here to offend anyone or jump to conclusions, only to give my opinion, and respond to other's. If I am wrong, I will say I'm wrong, and will apologize. I commend you for your contribution to your family, your job, etc. I like to put other ideas out there (hopefully it won't offend anyone) that's the beauty of freedom of speech, but I am able to stand corrected! Thanks for setting me straight!!

  52. October 19, 2008

    3:45 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenamd (Anonymous) says...

    Well said Midnightgypsy. I still disagree with the part about informants. No one is twisting their arms to do it. They can do whatever they want. They dont have to work with hunt. hunt uses them to get the bigger guys thats all. Sorry i said you sounded ignorant.

  53. October 19, 2008

    7:04 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    But what does HUNT do to people who will not work for them - make their lives a living hell. Dave refused to work of them and choose to go to trial, they really don't have a case against him and look what happened to him. There are also others in this town that have gone through the same thing - it seems like once they get your name they will not let you be - even when you are trying to get your life straight

  54. October 19, 2008

    7:36 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenamd (Anonymous) says...

    Alpenawomen,

    How is it that hunt gets these people to work for them. The answer is that they have dealt drugs themselves. If they don't want to work they probaly go to jail. Whats so difficult about that? They choose to break the law. hunt doesn't make them do it. Your dave is in jail for a reason. He obviously dealt drugs and beat someone or he would not be in a cage right now. How is that hunts fault? He is a criminal and he is were he belongs. doeson't a judge have to see it that way for him to be in jail? Get real alpenawomen. Thinking like yours is scary and kind of ghetto. Glad everyone doesn't think like you do. Just ignorant.

  55. October 19, 2008

    10:48 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    midnightgypsy (Anonymous) says...

    Thanks alpenamd, you are most forgiven, and thank you for respecting my opinion, as I do yours and everyone else's. You are also right when you say that drug dealers make their own choices, so to speak. They sure do...everyone has free will. For the most part I feel the Hunt team does a good service for the public, except letting some of the losers go that should be in the "cage", just to obtain their information, but I realize they have a job to do and just wish there were a better way. I am only opposed to putting people in harm's way, and for the bad guy getting off the hook for tattling on someone else. It doesn't seem fair! I am all for upholding the law, but sometimes the law officials make their own laws, and are not much better than the criminals! Anyway, when all is said and done, I hope and pray the guy that was hurt at the bar makes a full recovery, and hope the devil gets his due! My prayers go out to the family of the victim...

  56. October 19, 2008

    11:47 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    alpenamd
    my my are we not on a high horse, to be judge and jury for everyone in the legal system. Of course if you are arrested you are guilty - forget about the constution - As if our legal system has never put anyone in jail that has not belonged there?? If someone turns your name in to Hunt and they question you, you must be guilty, right! i know HUNT has a job to do, so start doing it, with all the hard drugs in this town, all the deaths that have occured due to overdoses, come on get this crap off the street first and formost. I just do not see that happening here, other wise we would not have the problems we are facing in this town.

  57. October 20, 2008

    12:37 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    bcuz (Anonymous) says...

    Well after reading every thing, I am seeing a lot of reasons, excuses, blaming, bickering and drama..from what I know..and I do know Dave , and Ron..Dave has gotten away with a lot to now and he has learned nothing, except dad's money covers his sins.Even his own grandmother..may she rest in peace..thought of him as a trouble maker..and hoped he'd someday learn a lesson..looks as the day may be soon coming..I am not a witness..just a citizen who is going by the posts here and the gossip..But I believe he did kick Ron when he was down..because he thought Ron snitched on him...a cowardly and vicious thing to do...and sounds like typical behavior for David..he has never had any type of concience..Driven by alcohol, drugs,sex, and the good times..This town has a long standing history of drug abuse and alcoholism..And anyone who frequents the bar scene knows that it is a breeding ground for violence and stupidity..trying to shift blame back on the bar is maybe sound...but the point is that person tending bar did not put the boots to Ron's head...And I hope the person that did gets what is coming to them in spades..as an example that it is time to stop this cycle of violence and tolerance in this town..It's time to put the boots to the boozers and druggies...they're all over the place and it is pathetic..to see the lives some of these people live...But I know one thing ..you can't help anyone till they wanna help themselves and sometimes it turns out they end up in this type of situation and now there will be no choice for them but to sober up...both of them..about time

  58. October 20, 2008

    3:15 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    mrsjimmyurine (Anonymous) says...

    so is that what the whole thing was about? Dave thought Ron snitched on him? between this article and the one before it, it seemed like it was because of Brandi, tho yes dave was with her awhile ago, he didnt want to be with her now, and HUNT should be focusing on the hard drugs, leave dave peddling short bags as it alone.

    VOTE YES ON PROP ONE, and maybe stuff like this wouldnt happen.....ahhhh i cant wait to read what will be posted after this....

  59. October 20, 2008

    8:31 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    HDALP (Anonymous) says...

    Dave knows who snitched on him....and it wasn't Ron. And a person is innocent until proven guilty...lets not forget that!!

  60. October 20, 2008

    9:04 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    no i don't want to be the judge of david, but from all the info i have recieved, it was, and really i wish it wasn't because i am friends with him also. ron does not blame his dad for his problems, he had a hard life but i have never heard him say "because of my dad". ron did not snitch on david it was dave blackabee and david knew this.

  61. October 20, 2008

    9:50 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    bcuz (Anonymous) says...

    well, like I said I knew it was gossip, thanx for clearing that up..but still begs the question,, why?? Makes no sense..I still stand on my opinions,except I now know I am wrong about ron narking him out..that is all I retract about my statement..which is again an opinion based on this site, and gossip, and what I know personally about David...

  62. October 20, 2008

    10:11 a.m.

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    (This comment was removed by the site staff.)

  63. October 20, 2008

    7:38 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    ski (Anonymous) says...

    what is ron's last name

  64. October 20, 2008

    8:02 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    blindjustice (Anonymous) says...

    Alpenawomen, amen sister. I commend you. Hey bcuz you really need to brush up on your skills as a human being. Also you should check into some type of educational classes, you are way out there. It sounds like your very jealous of David's expense account, and the life style and money his parents, Dave&Chris have. Please remember people are overly opinionated when they want what someone else has. Don't even try to bring up Dave Sr.s mother into this event. She was an overly opinionated women who disliked everyone. I hope you are never in court, I will presume you guilty, no matter who you are, what you have done, I will condem you, your family, insult your children, your grandparents. Get in your face where you work, and tell you, you are guilty, and I hope you burn in hell!!!! Let's See how you stuff that in your pipe and smoke it.......

  65. October 20, 2008

    8:44 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    WOW bcuz, what a hateful opinion you have expressed in your post. To condemn David, saying he was cowardly and vicious - then turn around and say put the boots to other!!?? What type of vigilantism are you supporting? Our forefathers set guidelines to prevent this type of behavior and with people like you in this world "Thank God" they did. To say someone acts without a conscious, the only people who truly do this are sociopaths - and David is far from that diagnose. You on the other hand may need help with your miss placed anger issues. I will be praying for you!

  66. October 21, 2008

    9:22 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    tiredoflies (Anonymous) says...

    I know Dave and I just was at his house not too long ago and I do want to say one thing. HE WAS STRAIGHTENING UP...If you know him you would defend him. I don't think he did it, but then who knows because I wasn't there. I sure hope he didn't do this...Does anyone know if Ashley's baby is his???? I sure hope not due to this and I feel bad for his child he already has.

  67. October 21, 2008

    10:12 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    alpenawomen (Anonymous) says...

    Is Ashley's baby his, she says so when she wants money, when she doesn't or he wont give her any it is not his baby. Feel bad for any or her children, she doesn't take care of the ones she has now!

  68. October 21, 2008

    10:17 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    never (Anonymous) says...

    I find it very funny when we have a man seriouly hurt and dont really no how the out come will be and people are asking questions like is ashleys baby daves. What does that have to do with whats going on with this case. Yes i feel bad for the children they dont choose there parents,because if they did they would not have chosen a mother like her either she already has kids she doent take care of. Earlier it was said that chains is taken credit for doing this to ron well i dont think he is and i do believe dave did this and then they left him there in his own blood how sad. i hope everyone involved gets whats coming to them how would you feel if it was one of yours, maybe some of you would change your stories then hey.

  69. October 21, 2008

    10:18 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    mrsjimmyurine (Anonymous) says...

    ashley who? and what does that have to do with this case

  70. October 21, 2008

    10:48 a.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    never (Anonymous) says...

    Exactly that was my point,it has nothein to do with the case it has to do with people spreading more rumors. Does any one reliable have the status on how Ron is doin?

  71. October 21, 2008

    12:26 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    dramafree (Anonymous) says...

    I am so amazed at how this scenario affects so many people in the area. Everyone makes (and is entitled to make) stupid choices while drunk or sober. Both men involved here apparently made bad choices in the past or they wouldn't be in the situation they are in now. I hope that the victim is going to be okay and make a full recovery. Hopefully, he will make some lifestyle changes in the end. As for the man behind bars, if he is truly responsible for this, I hope he pays for it. No circumstances excuse what has happened. None of this even changes or affects my life in any way. I am just someone with an opinion and I am exercising my constitutional right here!

    To the comment of Tuskie's overserving people - YOU are first & foremost responsible for knowing when you have had enough to drink and when it's time to call it a night...Not the bartenders! If you are getting too out of control, by all means the bartenders will cut you off and send you on your way. They are even great at calling you a cab if need be. I have seen it happen many times that I've been in there. I have been witness to very few fights there in the past years and have never seen either person involved in this case ever at Tuskie's.

    I hope that justice will be served and truly believe that one way or another karma comes back to bite you...

  72. October 21, 2008

    1:04 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    gina (Anonymous) says...

    ron is getting better every day. he had a little set back last night. he is very determined to get better and get out of the hospital. he definately has a long road ahead of him

  73. October 21, 2008

    1:57 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    never (Anonymous) says...

    gina thank you for sharing with the public on how Ron is doing it amazes me on the rumors. Yes people were walking around saying he past away last night. For the comment on the bar situation,yes iit is your responability to no when you had enough but look who we are dealing with and i have seen tuskies over surve and yes i will agree they will call a cab but its not that way everynite. But the one that are on trail here is dave,arron and mike if i forgot to ad someone here please forgive me. They each are big boys and made these problems for there selfs. As far as Dave he has had every oppurtunity given to him a good job with his dad making good money and yes dad has handed him alot,so he has no excuse for any of this. His dad has changed hes life around i wish people would stop lashing out at Dave Sr. He need s David to stand on his own two feet. If this were him getting hurt he would go after did this to his son so lets think about Rons family

  74. October 21, 2008

    3:32 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    tiredoflies (Anonymous) says...

    Children come first and for most. Her other 2 kids got taken away from their dad because of how horrible she is to them. Ashley Badgero is her name for those who asked. I worry about Ron and Dave too but you also have to think of how Dave's children will be effected especially his older one. People need to keep their noses out of it and just let
    the law take its course.

  75. October 21, 2008

    3:52 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    never (Anonymous) says...

    excuse me but her kids were taken away from her not there father he has custody!! They have a step-mother that is very good to them. This is not about ashley anyways this is about david she has nothing to do with this picture except that child she is carring, there are grandparent right to.

  76. October 21, 2008

    7:27 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    kmichgirl (Anonymous) says...

    I'm not going to participate in the bickering here, but as someone who grew up in Alpena and left for a bigger city, I get a kick out of how the entire town is on here arguing among themselves about a BAR FIGHT. That kind of thing wouldn't even make the news anywhere other than Alpena. I wish everyone would quit complaining about how the town is going to s**t and thank your lucky stars that the worst you have to worry about is a bar fight and some "graffiti on the north side." I have actual GANG graffiti in my neighborhood and the family across the driveway from mine was shot up in the middle of the night by some thug kids who were mad at the teenage son. Quit fighting each other and be glad you live in a place tight-knit enough where this kind of thing is actually big news!

  77. October 21, 2008

    8:22 p.m.

    northendlou (Anonymous) says...

    (This comment was removed by the site staff.)

  78. October 21, 2008

    9:08 p.m.
    Report inappropriate content

    dramafree (Anonymous) says...

    AMEN TO THAT NORTHENDLOU!

  79. October 21, 2008